Commentating on the race to the bottom

Yet again The BPPA finds itself responding to a piece by Professor Roy Greenslade on The Guardian’s website. Yet again Professor Greenslade adds his influential voice to the drastically mistaken notion that anyone can take a picture good enough for a newspaper these days. Seriously? Have you looked at some of the utter rubbish that gets used in some of our newspapers? To assert that anyone with a camera can take a picture isn’t only an insult to the skilled photographers who make silk purses out of sows ears on a daily basis it also invites the bean-counters who are behind the decisions to axe photographers jobs to question the need for written journalists too.

I can just imagine the conversation between the accountants and the owners with an editor sitting there listening to the conversation;

Owner: We need to save some more money. Sales are still in decline and sacking the photographers hasn’t saved us enough.

Accountant: Well, members of the public are providing all of our visual content so maybe we can get them to supply the words too.

Editor: But…

Owner: Brilliant idea. Let’s start with all of the senior reporters who really know what they are doing. Editor – we need you to sell this to the staff.

Editor: But…

Owner: They’re all scared for their jobs anyway. Accountant – you are a genius and you will be rewarded for your work with a big pay rise.

Editor: But…

Accountant: Thanks Owner, maybe we should discuss a few other money-saving ideas that I have over a drink or two. Do we NEED editors?

How long will it be before expensive columnists get their marching orders in favour of a few blokes with word processing software who “can write a bit”? Who will those people actually be? Will they be honest and concerned citizens or will they be people with an agenda and an axe to grind?

We are already at the stage where a large percentage of the ‘supplied’ images being printed in some papers are not properly checked for honesty, accuracy or ownership (not to mention quality). Beyond that, nobody seems to care whether members of the public are putting their own or other people’s lives in danger to get the pictures that they are giving away for free. Even Professor Greenslade has to agree that journalism stands or falls on its honesty and accuracy even if he has already thrown the towel in on quality.

One of the numerous responses to his Media Guardian article points out that very few people remember the words after the event compared to the number who remember the images. You might think that newspaper owners would forget this at their peril – unfortunately they have forgotten and their newspapers are in peril. Another response points out that newspaper decline could well be a chicken and egg discussion. Which did come first – the fall in sales or the loss of photographers?

This is rapidly becoming a race to the bottom and it really doesn’t help the case for quality newspapers and quality journalism when one of the highest profile commentators on the industry has given up on any notion of defending the simple idea that quality products have longevity and cheap ones don’t. We’d wonder if The Guardian’s own Picture Desk team would agree with The Professor’s odd logic or if its own sub-editors would approve of his fact checking.

Losing reporters would be the largest and most recent nail in the coffin of local and regional journalism. National newspapers, radio and television get a lot of their best people from the superb training ground that is (or maybe was) local journalism.

If I were contemplating training as a journalist right now I think that I’d have second thoughts about it. If the learned Professor is right maybe those currently on his course should consider switching to accountancy before it’s too late.

About these ads

13 thoughts on “Commentating on the race to the bottom

    • It’s a decent enough article, sadly about 20 years too late. I was banging on about this years ago but unfortunately no one was listening so the only thing left to me was to change professions (no I didn’t become an accountant). I became a writer and filmmaker.

  1. Using the “logic” in Roy Greenslade’s commentary if anyone can do anything then wild animals randomly bashing away at a keyboard would at some point end up with the same article that he wrote.

    The reason why his article carries so much weight and is so damaging to the photographic profession is the experience and expertise his name adds to it.

    To say that professional photographers add nothing to images of every day events is insulting.

    Yes, let us have a debate about the future of press photography. But first you have to acknowledge that professional press photographers have the ability to add to the reporting of an event that no amateur with a camera phone will ever do.

  2. Hmm, well where I’ve just left has actually done away with the Editors of 2 national titles, oh and photogs are now lumped in as “visual journalists”

  3. wot, the same professor greenslade who was features editor on the star when we woz young?

  4. Pingback: Photographers snap back - drivel, rubbish, moronic - but I am right - technology news

  5. Pingback: Photographers snap back – drivel, rubbish, moronic – but I am right – The Guardian | Best Photo Market

  6. Pingback: Photographers snap back – drivel, rubbish, moronic – but I am right | FREE Article Distribution, Press Release Distribution, News Distribution - No Registration! Submit a Free Article or Press Release | BUZZSTAKE

  7. Pingback: Photographers snap back – drivel, rubbish, moronic – but I am right

  8. Pingback: Photographers snap back – drivel, rubbish, moronic – but I am right | ManSwag

  9. Pingback: Photographers snap back – drivel, rubbish, moronic – but I am right | Tech Quotient

  10. Pingback: End of the local pro? | Glopho Blog

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s